Reviews

A Brooklyn Hipster in British Family Court

Club Kid (2026 | USA | 122 minutes | Jordan Firstman)

The first time I saw the trailer for Club Kid, I thought, “this is going to be a predictable family melodrama, albeit one with a hip and queer protagonist, and it’s going to make me cry like an infant.” The second through fiftieth time (it’s from A24, where the “A” stands for “always everywhere”), I thought, “this is going to be a predictable family melodrama, albeit one with a hip and queer protagonist, and it’s going to make me cry like an infant.” And now that I’ve actually seen it, my final judgment is: “this is a predictable family melodrama, albeit one with a hip and queer protagonist, and it made me cry like an infant.”

Jordan Firstman writes, directs, and stars in his feature filmmaking debut. What I found particularly impressive about Firstman’s debut is that he fully embraces familiarity and leaves his own imprint on a story that’s been told countless times before.

He stars as Peter, a promoter in New York’s underground scene who has built a reputation for throwing the best parties and providing the best drugs. He’s a hot mess because his ascension was not a sober one and he’s soon forced out of his partnership with Sophie (Cara Delevingne) for being too hungover to meet with investors.

I was least impressed with the story’s treatment of Sophie, the main antagonist and whose portrayal falls somewhere between borderline and overt misogyny. After years of being left holding the bag for Peter’s irresponsibility and immaturity, her anger toward him seemed more than a little justified to me. If her public humiliation and spiral into addiction (not to mention the vulgar insult hurled at her from a ten year old in the ubiquitous trailer) hadn’t been so enthusiastically celebrated by the “progressive” Seattle audience I saw the movie with, I might chalk it up to Firstman’s inexperience as a screenwriter.

Sophie’s downfall neatly coincides with Peter’s redemptive arc, as he’s forced to mature at an ungodly pace when Arlo enters his life.

Arlo is Peter’s ten-year-old biological son, who’s lived in London his entire life until his mother dies tragically and a woman named Edison leaves him in Peter’s care. This comes as a surprise to Peter, mostly because he thought his preference for the gentlemen was absolute.

Arlo is, by any objective measure, awesome. Even by Brooklyn hipster standards, he’s unbelievably precocious. Before long, he’s making trans friends and DJing Peter’s parties. Reggie Absolom is terrific in this role.

The bond between Peter and Arlo grows intense, Peter makes remarkable progress toward adulthood while Arlo thrives in his new environment. But the laws of melodrama are ironclad, and Peter must demonstrate that remaining in his care is in Arlo’s best interests. After all, this is a legal system where biology does not trump international law, but Venmo emojis can carry significant weight.

There’s nothing particularly surprising about where Club Kid takes us, and I suspect Firstman knows that perfectly well. But between his appealing performance, a star-making turn from Reggie Absolom, and a willingness to embrace the most reliable tricks in the melodrama playbook, he makes it difficult not to care. I knew exactly what was coming, and I cried anyway.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

_____________________________________

Club Kid opens in theaters in the Seattle area on Friday, November 20.