Reviews

What would make Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping a satisfying final chapter?

Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
(2026 | US | 158 minutes | Francis Lawrence)

The newest edition of the Hunger Games franchise fills in the gaps of the mysterious and traumatizing games Haymitch participated in that led him to be the insufferable lush we know him to be… but it also informs why he was so passionate about helping Katniss break down the walls of The Capitol. We find him young, beautiful, curly-haired and happily in love with a strong-willed covey girl Lenore (Whitney Peak) Sound familiar? Look no further than Snow and mentee Lucy Grey from Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. Lenore acts out at the reaping which leads to Haymitch unceremoniously becoming one of the 4 tributes from District 12 for the 50th Hunger Games. What follows is a blur of quick action sequences, garish clothing and lots and lots of trauma-inducing fear tactics.

I’ll start with: I love the Hunger Games book series. I had already finished the ones available at the time before the debut of the first film. I absolutely adored each and every addition to the story on the big screen. They didn’t making it fluffy, gloss over things because they’re ugly or overdo it on the lovey dovey (much of which I have a feeling is due to author Suzanne Collins being involved in the making of the films). Perhaps there were a few heavy-handed moments, but I never felt like it was overdone or full of itself.

Fast forward to this new installment The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. I have not read this book, so I’m wondering if that has a big part in coloring my opinion of the movie so take that for what it is. I’ve been eager to discover the story of Haymitch, so when the movie was on the horizon I had to be there for it… but I just couldn’t make time for the novel. The production value of these films never disappoints and the cast was stellar from start to finish. Which is why I’m all the more disappointed at the feeling of disconnection I was left with as a I walked out of the theater. In the first film, the connection we felt with Katniss and Peeta was intense and deep. They spent a lot of time on screen so that makes sense. However, I felt that same connection, if a bit less, to many of the other tributes involved in the story even if they were “bad”.

Haymitch (Joseph Zada) was the focus, but we were given a lot of time with Lenore his love interest but only on the surface. Maybe that’s the disconnection I’m feeling, we weren’t given real insight into any of the characters and there was plenty of opportunity. Even 5-10 lines could have done the trick, especially with the talent that shined like a star in every frame. Kieran Culkin was magnificent as the young Ceasar, McKenna Grace stole every scene she was a part of with scant speaking parts throughout, Jesse Plemons did justice to the game maker Plutarch in Philip Seymour Hoffman’s stead, Elle Fanning played the stylist and budding mentor Effie Trinket with emotional depth despite limited opportunities and last but not least Glen Close was effectively hideous inside and out as the condescending and grotesque head mentor Drusilla Sickle. Each and every one of these characters and actors were given less than they deserved. I know the story had to keep moving forward and there are certain choices that must be made, but a well-crafted script and body language can make a world of difference.

Something else that jumped out at me was the diversity of the characters, or should I say lack there of. This series is well-known to be inclusive. There was even an insane and unfounded uproar during the lead up to the first film when Amandla Sternberg was cast as Rue. A woman of color playing such a pivotal role, how dare they! (tl;dr it was written into the book that way) There were so many instances of strong female characters as well as those of color that graced the big screen throughout the series. It made me love the franchise and Collins’ work that much more.

Unfortunately that has fallen to the wayside in Sunrise on the Reaping. I could count characters of color in this film basically on one hand: the love interest who played no real part in the script other than being Haymitch’s reason for going to the games, Ben Wang is Wyatt Callow (Ben did an amazing job despite very little to work with) a tribute from 12, the beefy and aggressive career tribute character Panache (Jhaleil Swaby) from District 1 who was so surface you could practically call him a caricature. That’s pretty much it. I want to dote on Wang especially. After seeing him in a much jucier role in Stephen King’s The Long Walk, I can tell he has so much potential that he’s practically bursting at the seams. I have a feeling a lot of his screen time ended up on the cutting room floor because the moments he did have seemed a little out of place without more context. He was especially considerate and protective of the fourth, fill-in, tribute Lou Lou (Molly McCann) from 12, but we have no idea why. He seems like a really good kid despite being in a family of “Booker Boys” who bet on the games’ outcome (though, again, no other back story was offered *at all* about him, entirely frustrating) but why does he care about this young woman who they only met the day before? There’s so much gold to mine there and it was lost in the ether.

So you could say I have mixed feelings about the film. I love the franchise, seeing callbacks to all our “favorite” characters like Ceasar, Wiress, Beetee, Haymitch of course, and Effie… but the nostalgia doesn’t make up for some of these glaring shortcomings. I still really enjoyed the story and the film-going experience so I wouldn’t let these elements stop you, but I’d be doing a lousy job as a critic if I didn’t bring them up.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping arrives in theaters on 11/20